Comparativa hard disk

Xbit labs ha pubblicato, a questo indirizzo, una prova comparativa tra 7 differenti hard disk EIDE dotati di piatti capaci di memorizzare 20 Gbytes di dati ciascuno. Sono stati testati i modelli:
- Seagate U5
- Seagate Barracuda ATA III
- Quantum Fireball Plus AS
- Quantum Fireball lct20
- Western Digital Protege (WD200EB)
- Western Digital Caviar (WD200BB)
- Fujitsu MPG3204AT.
- Seagate U5
- Seagate Barracuda ATA III
- Quantum Fireball Plus AS
- Quantum Fireball lct20
- Western Digital Protege (WD200EB)
- Western Digital Caviar (WD200BB)
- Fujitsu MPG3204AT.
As for the first prize, we don't have any doubts about it, because here our subjective impressions were fully backed up by the testing results. Quantum Fireball Plus AS deserved the first prize for high results shown in Business Disk WinBench and excellent performance in IOMeter. We should also mention low average seek time and no problems in UDMA33 mode. This hard disk drive is the quietest of all and dissipates less heat.
The second prize is given to WD200BB. Although it proved not very well in Business Disk WinBench, it managed to regain its reputation in Win2000 + NTFS.
Despite really impressive muscles, Seagate Barracuda ATA III won only the third prize. This HDD performed not very well in UDMA33 mode and IOMeter. In file tests it looked better, though failed to beat WD200BB. The only thing that justifies it is the fact that we had only a sample, and not a mass piece. Maybe with new firmware this hard disk appears better.
0 Commenti
Gli autori dei commenti, e non la redazione, sono responsabili dei contenuti da loro inseriti - infoDevi effettuare il login per poter commentare
Se non sei ancora registrato, puoi farlo attraverso questo form.
Se sei già registrato e loggato nel sito, puoi inserire il tuo commento.
Si tenga presente quanto letto nel regolamento, nel rispetto del "quieto vivere".