H!H
06-06-2014, 15:40
Buongiorno a tutti
Sono in procinto di comprare un router WiFi per installare una LAN \ Wifi Lan.
Avrei bisogno dei feedback in merito a due router Dual Band Wifi che ho selezionato:
il primo: Linksys Smart Wi-Fi Router EA4500 Dual-Band N900 Router with Gigabit and USB (http://store.linksys.com/Routers/Linksys-EA4500-Dual-Band-N900-Router-with-Gigabit-USB_stcVVproductId145330245VVcatId551966VVviewprod.htm)
- ASUS RT-N66U vs Linksys EA4500 / EA4200v2 Wireless Retest benchmark (http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/wireless/wireless-reviews/32103-asus-rt-n66u-and-linksys-ea4500-ea4200v2-wireless-retest)
il secondo: Asus RT-N66U Dual-Band Wireless-N900 Gigabit Router Dark Knight (http://www.hwupgrade.it/forum/showthread.php?t=2448141)
- ASUS RT-N66U Dual-Band Wireless-N900 Gigabit Routing performance. (http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/wireless/wireless-reviews/31687-asus-rt-n66u-dark-knight-dual-band-wireless-n900-gigabit-router-reviewed)
Leggendo i benchmark sembra nettamente superiore l'Asus:
The main difference is that the RT-N66U's throughput baseline is higher than the Linksys'. (http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/wireless/wireless-reviews/32103-asus-rt-n66u-and-linksys-ea4500-ea4200v2-wireless-retest)
I alerted Linksys to the problem I found with downlink throughput around two weeks ago and checked back with them today before posting this retest. The good news is that they have preliminary results that point to an incompatibility in the Marvell chipset that the E4200v2 / EA4500 use and the Broadcom draft 802.11ac device used in the ASUS PCE-AC66U adapter.
The additional good news, I guess, is that there are currently not a lot of draft 802.11ac client adapters in the wild. Any that are out there use Broadcom chipsets and could show the problem I've found if used with the E4200v2, EA4500 or any other router using the Marvell 88W8063 dual-band 3x3 MAC/BB. These include the Linksys EA3500 and D-Link DIR-665.
But this is just conjecture at this point. The only thing I can say for sure is that you'll find the problem with the E4200v2 and EA4500, at least until either Marvell, Broadcom, Linksys or some combination of them fix it. When and if they do, we'll be happy to retest the E4200v2 / EA4500 once again to see if it can gain some ground in the Router Ranker.
Updated 5/21/2013
So to not be the spreader of unfounded rumors, I ran quick tests on three draft 802.11ac adapters with the EA4500 to see if they also showed the low downlink throughput problem. The short story is neither the NETGEAR A6200 USB adapter, based on the Broadcom BCM43526 2x2 802.11ac transceiver, nor the Linksys AE6000 USB adapter, using Mediatek MT7610 1x1 802.11ac chipset nor the Linksys WUMC710 Media Connector (bridge), which appears to use the same Broadcom 3x3 BCM4360 802.11ac transceiver as the ASUS PCE-AC66 PCIe Adapter showed the problem. So at this point, the low downlink throughput problem appears to be unique to the ASUS PCE-AC66.
La cosa interessante dell' asus è la possibilità di poter installare Firmaware opensource vedi Merlin, DDWRT, Tomato.
Immagino sia possibile anche sui linksys... (attualmente AE4500 non supporta il DD-WRT perchè porta a bordo un chipset Marvell 88W8063 non compatibile).
L' infrastruttura della LAN che sto progettando è composta così (inserisco il link all' image se no spagina :p )
http://i.imgur.com/LajNyEz.png
i componenti di rete da inserire nell' infrastruttra LAN\Wifi sono:
- NAS Synology DS 214 Play (http://lucascalvi.it/2014/02/synology-ds214-play-nas-recensione-e-benchmark-wd-western-digital-RED-4TB-ds214play)
- Minix Neo X7 (http://www.minix.com.hk/Products/MINIX-NEOX7.html)
- 2 Wifi IP Cam infrared
Veniamo al dunque, volevo un consiglio sulla scelta del router Wifi immagino che qui ci sono utenti che hanno esperienza diretta e pratica con i sopracitati router.
Lo scopo dell 'infrastruttura è di supportare un private cloud, streaming audio, streaming video HD\DNLA, ip cam surveillance.
Diciamo che le prestazioni della rete wifi deve essere solida e performante.
Ho letto che il "Cisco Cloud Connect" che permette di amminstrare "anywhere" il tuo router non è molto consigliato per la privacy dei dati ... qualcuno ha maggiori info su questo tema?
Accetto consigli suggerimenti.
Se ho dimenticato di citare qualche particolare chiedete pure.
Ringrazio anticipatemente.
Sono in procinto di comprare un router WiFi per installare una LAN \ Wifi Lan.
Avrei bisogno dei feedback in merito a due router Dual Band Wifi che ho selezionato:
il primo: Linksys Smart Wi-Fi Router EA4500 Dual-Band N900 Router with Gigabit and USB (http://store.linksys.com/Routers/Linksys-EA4500-Dual-Band-N900-Router-with-Gigabit-USB_stcVVproductId145330245VVcatId551966VVviewprod.htm)
- ASUS RT-N66U vs Linksys EA4500 / EA4200v2 Wireless Retest benchmark (http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/wireless/wireless-reviews/32103-asus-rt-n66u-and-linksys-ea4500-ea4200v2-wireless-retest)
il secondo: Asus RT-N66U Dual-Band Wireless-N900 Gigabit Router Dark Knight (http://www.hwupgrade.it/forum/showthread.php?t=2448141)
- ASUS RT-N66U Dual-Band Wireless-N900 Gigabit Routing performance. (http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/wireless/wireless-reviews/31687-asus-rt-n66u-dark-knight-dual-band-wireless-n900-gigabit-router-reviewed)
Leggendo i benchmark sembra nettamente superiore l'Asus:
The main difference is that the RT-N66U's throughput baseline is higher than the Linksys'. (http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/wireless/wireless-reviews/32103-asus-rt-n66u-and-linksys-ea4500-ea4200v2-wireless-retest)
I alerted Linksys to the problem I found with downlink throughput around two weeks ago and checked back with them today before posting this retest. The good news is that they have preliminary results that point to an incompatibility in the Marvell chipset that the E4200v2 / EA4500 use and the Broadcom draft 802.11ac device used in the ASUS PCE-AC66U adapter.
The additional good news, I guess, is that there are currently not a lot of draft 802.11ac client adapters in the wild. Any that are out there use Broadcom chipsets and could show the problem I've found if used with the E4200v2, EA4500 or any other router using the Marvell 88W8063 dual-band 3x3 MAC/BB. These include the Linksys EA3500 and D-Link DIR-665.
But this is just conjecture at this point. The only thing I can say for sure is that you'll find the problem with the E4200v2 and EA4500, at least until either Marvell, Broadcom, Linksys or some combination of them fix it. When and if they do, we'll be happy to retest the E4200v2 / EA4500 once again to see if it can gain some ground in the Router Ranker.
Updated 5/21/2013
So to not be the spreader of unfounded rumors, I ran quick tests on three draft 802.11ac adapters with the EA4500 to see if they also showed the low downlink throughput problem. The short story is neither the NETGEAR A6200 USB adapter, based on the Broadcom BCM43526 2x2 802.11ac transceiver, nor the Linksys AE6000 USB adapter, using Mediatek MT7610 1x1 802.11ac chipset nor the Linksys WUMC710 Media Connector (bridge), which appears to use the same Broadcom 3x3 BCM4360 802.11ac transceiver as the ASUS PCE-AC66 PCIe Adapter showed the problem. So at this point, the low downlink throughput problem appears to be unique to the ASUS PCE-AC66.
La cosa interessante dell' asus è la possibilità di poter installare Firmaware opensource vedi Merlin, DDWRT, Tomato.
Immagino sia possibile anche sui linksys... (attualmente AE4500 non supporta il DD-WRT perchè porta a bordo un chipset Marvell 88W8063 non compatibile).
L' infrastruttura della LAN che sto progettando è composta così (inserisco il link all' image se no spagina :p )
http://i.imgur.com/LajNyEz.png
i componenti di rete da inserire nell' infrastruttra LAN\Wifi sono:
- NAS Synology DS 214 Play (http://lucascalvi.it/2014/02/synology-ds214-play-nas-recensione-e-benchmark-wd-western-digital-RED-4TB-ds214play)
- Minix Neo X7 (http://www.minix.com.hk/Products/MINIX-NEOX7.html)
- 2 Wifi IP Cam infrared
Veniamo al dunque, volevo un consiglio sulla scelta del router Wifi immagino che qui ci sono utenti che hanno esperienza diretta e pratica con i sopracitati router.
Lo scopo dell 'infrastruttura è di supportare un private cloud, streaming audio, streaming video HD\DNLA, ip cam surveillance.
Diciamo che le prestazioni della rete wifi deve essere solida e performante.
Ho letto che il "Cisco Cloud Connect" che permette di amminstrare "anywhere" il tuo router non è molto consigliato per la privacy dei dati ... qualcuno ha maggiori info su questo tema?
Accetto consigli suggerimenti.
Se ho dimenticato di citare qualche particolare chiedete pure.
Ringrazio anticipatemente.